What Is a Lemon Car? How to Check a VIN for Lemon History

A lemon is a new car the maker had to take back. Most of them don't get scrapped: they get fixed and sold again. Here's how to tell before you buy one.

By VinItel Research TeamPublished

Every state has a lemon law. If a new car has a serious defect that the dealer can't fix after several tries, the manufacturer has to replace it or buy it back. The buyer who complained is made whole. The car itself usually goes to auction, gets repaired and is sold to someone else.

That second buyer is the one who needs to know. A lemon brand on the title is the warning, and it only helps if you look for it.

Chart: of 41 lemon-branded cars, 40 were titled again, 35 listed for sale again and 10 titled in another state
41 cars with a lemon brand in VinItel's title records and what happened next. Source: VinItel title and listing records.

What 41 lemon-branded cars did next

Lemon brands are rare in title records, so treat this as a small sample, not a national rate. Still, the pattern is clear:

  • 40 of 41 were titled again after the lemon brand was added. A buyback is not the end of a car's road.
  • 35 of 41 were listed for sale again after the brand.
  • 10 of 41 were later titled in another state. Each state brands titles its own way, so the state where the car ends up may word the brand differently, or not show it at all.
  • 29 of 41 got the brand within two years of their first title; the median was about 19 months. Lemon laws mostly cover the first year or two, or the first 12,000 to 24,000 miles.
  • They're not just cheap cars. The list includes Land Rovers (7), Fords (6), Teslas, Audis, Bentleys, an Aston Martin and a Cadillac Escalade.

Two real lemons

Title timelines for a 2016 Tesla Model X branded lemon in California in 2016 and later titled in Florida, and a 2020 Land Rover Defender branded lemon in Georgia in 2022
Title and listing dates for two lemon-branded cars. Red: the lemon brand. Orange: listed for sale. Source: VinItel records.

2016 Tesla Model X P90D, VIN 5YJXCBE49GFS00707

First titled in California in January 2016 and branded a lemon there in November 2016, ten months later. It was titled again in 2017, listed for sale with 11,514 miles in May 2021 and then titled in Florida, where it has been re-titled several more times since.

2020 Land Rover Defender 110 SE, VIN SALEP7EU2L2004025

Titled in New York and Connecticut, branded a lemon in Georgia in June 2022 and titled again in Georgia a month later and in 2023. It was listed for sale again in 2023, by December with 62,455 miles on it.

Neither history is unusual for a buyback. What matters is whether the person who bought each car next knew.

How to check if a car is a lemon

  1. Look at the whole title history, not the current title. A brand added in one state may be worded differently, or missing, on a later title from another state. A VIN report shows every title with its date and state.
  2. Search for the words. "Lemon", "Lemon Law Buyback", "Manufacturer Buyback", "Warranty Return" and "Reacquired" all point to the same thing.
  3. Watch for a manufacturer as an owner. A title issued to the carmaker or its finance arm, right after a short first ownership, is a buyback sign.
  4. Check recalls and the repair history. Repeated visits for the same problem (engine, transmission, electrical, infotainment that won't stay fixed) are what lemon claims are made of.
  5. Ask in writing. "Was this car ever bought back by the manufacturer?" Many states require sellers to disclose it.

Is a lemon buyback ever worth buying?

Sometimes. A buyback that was fixed by the manufacturer, with the repair documented, can be a fair deal at a real discount. Go in knowing:

  • What the defect was, and whether it's fixed for good.
  • What's left of the factory warranty. Some makers transfer it, some limit it.
  • That the brand stays with the car, so it will be worth less when you sell it.
  • That some lenders and insurers treat a lemon-branded title like other branded titles.

The bad deal is the one where you don't know. A buyback sold at a clean-title price is the same problem as a washed salvage title: the paperwork you're shown doesn't tell the whole story.

Questions buyers ask

What is a lemon car?

A new car with a serious defect the manufacturer couldn't fix after a reasonable number of repair attempts, usually within the first one or two years. Under state lemon laws the maker has to replace the car or buy it back. A car bought back this way is often called a lemon or a manufacturer buyback.

Can a lemon car be sold again?

Yes. Most states let the manufacturer resell a bought-back car once it's repaired, but many require the title to be branded (for example "Lemon", "Lemon Law Buyback" or "Manufacturer Buyback") and the buyer to be told in writing. Rules and wording differ from state to state.

How do I check if a car is a lemon?

Run a VIN check for title brands across the car's whole history, not just the current title. Look for a lemon or buyback brand, a title issued to the manufacturer, or a very short first ownership. Then check the recalls and the repair history, and ask the seller directly whether the car was ever bought back.

Is it bad to buy a lemon buyback car?

Not always. Some buybacks were fixed properly and sell at a real discount. The risk is buying one without knowing: you pay a normal price, the defect may come back, the factory warranty may be limited, and the car will be harder to sell later. Know what the defect was before you decide.

Does a lemon brand stay on the title?

It's supposed to, and in many states it must be carried onto every later title. In practice a later title from another state may not show it, which is why the full title history matters more than the title in the seller's hand.

About the numbers

The 41 cars are every vehicle carrying a "Lemon" brand in VinItel's title records, which cover title events reported by states. Brands are recorded unevenly, so this is a sample of lemons we can see, not a count of all of them. "Titled again" counts any later title record; "listed for sale" counts any later sale listing. Lemon laws and title branding rules vary by state; check your state's consumer protection or DMV office for the exact rules. More: every title brand explained and the used car buying checklist.

Topics in this article
  • #lemon car
  • #lemon law
  • #manufacturer buyback
  • #lemon title
  • #branded title
  • #VIN check
  • #used car buying